ACLU sues four top Obama administration officials over Verizon metadata sharing

Cyrus Farivar
Ars Technica
June 12, 2013


Group wants a judge to declare that “the Mass Call Tracking is unlawful.”

acluThe American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) filed a lawsuit Tuesday against four high-level government officials, arguing that Verizon’s ongoing sharing of telephone metadata to the National Security Agency (NSA) is unconstitutional.

The officials include Director of National Intelligence James Clapper, Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel, Director of the FBI Robert Mueller, and Attorney General Eric Holder.

The ACLU is asking a federal judge to declare the entire program unlawful, halt it, and purge all related records—admittedly a tall order.

The ACLU’s legal filing (PDF) states that the disclosure of what numbers were called and when could potentially damage the group in future advocacy work.

The government’s surveillance of their [the ACLU's] communications (hereinafter “Mass Call Tracking”) allows the government to learn sensitive and privileged information about their work and clients, and it is likely to have a chilling effect on whistleblowers and others who would otherwise contact Plaintiffs for legal assistance. This surveillance is not authorized by Section 215 and violates the First and Fourth Amendments. Plaintiffs bring this suit to obtain a declaration that the Mass Call Tracking is unlawful; to enjoin the government from continuing the Mass Call Tracking under [Verizon’s] order or any successor thereto; and to require the government to purge from its databases all of the call records related to Plaintiffs’ communications collected pursuant to the Mass Call Tracking.

Christopher Allen, a spokesperson for the FBI, told Ars that “per policy the FBI does not comment on pending legal matters.”

“This dragnet program is surely one of the largest surveillance efforts ever launched by a democratic government against its own citizens,” ACLU Deputy Legal Director Jameel Jaffer said in a statement. “It is the equivalent of requiring every American to file a daily report with the government of every location they visited, every person they talked to on the phone, the time of each call, and the length of every conversation. The program goes far beyond even the permissive limits set by the Patriot Act and represents a gross infringement of the freedom of association and the right to privacy.”

Read the full article—ACLU sues four top Obama administration officials over Verizon metadata sharing